top of page

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Thanks for submitting!

What Would You Make If You Could Work in Another Medium?

13 minutes ago
4 min read

A photographer can now sketch a soundtrack, and an editor can prototype a design without mastering every application first. That opens a door. Walking through it still means learning how the new medium works, and recognizing whose expertise the finished piece needs.


Imagine someone who has spent years making portraits. They know how to direct a subject, notice light and decide when a frame feels right. Now they want that portrait to become the opening of a short film, with movement, narration and a soundscape. A few years ago, the technical barriers alone might have ended the idea. Today, a tool might help them test an early version.


I keep coming back to what happens after that first version appears. Does the photographer learn something about film and sound? Do they find a collaborator who knows those crafts? Or do they stop at an output that looks finished because the software made it look convincing?


A doorway into work you have never done


Adobe's November 10 announcements at MAX showed how its software is moving across traditional boundaries. Adobe described Firefly Graph, a beta for building reusable workflows, and Firefly Builder, a private beta intended to help people prototype websites and apps with natural-language instructions. Adobe Research also described tools that help editors generate and adjust audio inside a video timeline. These are different products at different stages, and the company's demonstrations are not independent measures of how well they perform on a client's assignment.


Still, the direction is clear enough to ask a useful question: What would you attempt if the first version no longer required months of software lessons?


A designer might test motion for a poster. A filmmaker might try illustrating a treatment. Someone who tells stories through still images might hear how music changes the feeling of the same scene. That exploration can be worthwhile even when the first attempt is rough. A sketch can help a person communicate an idea that once lived only in their head.


Black-and-white portrait of two people behind a balustrade and repeating columns.
Portfolio photograph supplied by Theoplis Stewart II. Illustrative, not an AI or cross-media experiment.

The medium has its own rules


A still photograph controls one moment. A film controls duration, sequence and what changes between moments. Audio has its own rhythm, space and emotional cues. An interactive experience asks where a visitor clicks, what happens next and how it behaves when something fails. Tools may share a screen, but the decisions are different.


Take an imagined thirty-second portrait film. A generator may suggest a moving camera and background music. The editor still has to decide whether the movement fits the subject, whether a sound competes with the voice and whether the pace gives the audience enough time to notice the important moment. If the scene makes a factual claim, someone has to verify it. If a performer appears, permission and context still matter.


A first prototype might be enough to invite a conversation with a composer, sound designer, developer or animator. Treating that person's craft as interchangeable with a button risks missing what makes the idea work. A new tool should create room for collaboration as well as experimentation.


Access and authorship are different questions


Adobe surveyed nearly 2,000 creatives in the United States, United Kingdom and Japan in research published in June. The company reported that its largest attitude group, 41%, was a pragmatic middle: people open to AI but not fully persuaded. Adobe sells the technology being evaluated, and these were survey responses rather than observed creative outcomes. They are useful evidence that people are making different decisions about where the tools belong.


There is also a reminder from a 2024 experiment published in Science Advances. Writers given AI story ideas sometimes produced stories rated more creative individually, while their stories were more similar to one another as a group. That experiment concerned short fiction, not filmmaking, music or photography. It suggests a question worth testing rather than a law about every medium: If many people take the same convenient starting point, how different do their results become?


The answer may depend on the material brought into the process. A photographer can begin with a real image they made, a place they know or a subject who agreed to participate. A musician can begin with a recording, a rhythm or a tradition they have studied. That starting material matters because the work carries decisions and relationships that no prompt can supply on its own.


A person jumps with arms raised in front of a bright pink backdrop outdoors, with two people seated nearby.
Portfolio photograph supplied by Theoplis Stewart II. Illustrative, not a generated or cross-media project.

Try crossing one boundary, then study the gaps


I would like to see more experiments that make these differences visible. Choose something you already know how to do, such as a photo essay, and translate one part into another form. Make a short audio piece that accompanies the images, or a simple interactive sequence that lets people explore the story in a different order. Use an assistant if it helps, but keep the source files and describe what the assistant did.


Then ask someone experienced in the second medium to look at it. Where did the timing fail? What did the new form reveal that the photographs could not? Which choices need a human performer, editor or developer? Try one revision by hand. This is a proposed exercise, not a test I have conducted.


There are practical limits. Copyright and licensing are not settled merely because an application exports a file. In January 2025, the U.S. Copyright Office said AI-assisted work may qualify for copyright protection where sufficient human creative expression is present, while prompts alone do not necessarily establish that authorship. That guidance is general; the rights to a particular image, recording or performance still need their own review.


The opportunity here is bigger than making one person responsible for every discipline. A photographer who understands a little sound can direct a sound designer more thoughtfully. An editor who learns basic interaction can make a clearer prototype for a developer. And someone who discovers they love a new medium has a reason to study it beyond the easiest first result.


If the next tool gives you access to a different craft, what will you make that helps you understand that craft better?


Sources and further reading






Comments


Join our mailing list

©2024-2026 by Theoplis Stewart II.

bottom of page